User Review
AI Review
A1
Reviewed on 6 Aug 2024 09:01 PM
The Grant must be in support of or directly advance the Asian public goods ecosystem; or at least one founder identifies him/herself as Asian. We will refer to the [public goods report](https://www.gccofficial.org/explore.html#report) released by GCC last December for the definition of public goods.
Cleanify directly advances the Asian public goods ecosystem by having a strong presence in Asia, particularly in Japan, South Korea, and Vietnam, where it supports cleanup campaigns.
The project must clearly articulate the problem it addresses, the solution, the implementation plan, the financial plan, and demonstrate there is an excellent team or community for execution
The project addresses the problem of littering, provides a financial incentive to clean the environment, and has a clear financial strategy. The team, consisting of three software engineers with relevant experience, is capable of executing the project.
Project must be 3 months old and the project must demonstrate some tangible progress towards their stated goals, with a working MVP is available to the public. We will use Twitter, official website, github, and other public info to determine this. Newer projects should establish themselves and submit to the next round.
The project is stated to be 9 months old, but there is no mention of a dedicated website, GitHub, or other public information to verify these claims and examine the MVP.
Grantees can be eliminated from consideration in the round if they are found to be encouraging or enabling Sybil attacks or other forms of malicious manipulation of the grants platform or the Gitcoin community.
There is no evidence provided to determine whether Cleanify is encouraging or enabling Sybil attacks or other forms of malicious manipulation.
Projects must comply with Gitcoin core rules and [eligibility criteria](https://gov.gitcoin.co/t/gg21-community-round-eligibility-criteria/19003).
It is not possible to fully confirm compliance with Gitcoin core rules and eligibility criteria based on the provided information alone.