User Review
AI Review
A1
Reviewed on 15 Apr 2024 05:00 PM
Advance the field of token engineering (tldr; economics and system design with crypto / design and analysis of cryptoeconomic systems)
The Breadchain Cooperative's project description indicates their focus on developing 'solidarity primitives' like the Crowdstaking Application, which can contribute to advancements in economic design in the crypto space, relating to the funding and governance of cooperative projects. This indeed aligns with the advancements in the field of token engineering.
Focus on token engineering research, education, software development and/or social infrastructure
The project's Crowdstaking Application demonstrates an active focus on software development within the token engineering space. Additionally, their initiative towards establishing a network of governing resources implies contributions to social infrastructure.
Be a public good
The Breadchain Cooperative's aim to develop sustainable funding and governance models for cooperative projects through blockchain technology indicates their commitment to public goods, as they are focused on non-financialized forms of coordination and open governance.
Specify your short-term goals (within the scope of the grant) and long-term vision of their projects
The project's grant proposal provides clear short-term goals, which include the development of additional 'solidarity primitives', and a long-term vision of establishing a vibrant ecosystem for collective governance, which aligns well with the grant's purpose.
Provide some proof of already existing work and list any recent milestones, even if small, to be included into the round
The Github activity indicates substantial engagement with multiple repositories and milestones such as open and closed pull requests, and issues. This, along with the provided link to an in-depth walkthrough of their Crowdstaking Application, serves as proof of already existing work and progress.
Have a project update - If you are a returning grantee, you must provide an update on what work has been accomplished since the last grant round your project received funding from
Without information on prior grant rounds and updates post those grants, it’s unclear if this criteria is met. The project’s description does not mention prior grants or updates which makes it uncertain.
Have a verified Twitter account
The provided Twitter link leads to an account, but there's no indication that the account is verified. Twitter's verified badge is missing from the provided project Twitter account.