OpenGuitar
Open-source project promoting STEAM education through assembling classical guitars, targeting disadvantaged children. Aims to empower music educators and create a cyber-physical infrastructure.Application
Applied on: 5 Aug 2024 02:24 PM
Rejected
User Review
AI Review
A1
Reviewed on 5 Aug 2024 03:02 PM
CollabTech project - organisations on-chain, evolution of B2B SaaS, network states tooling & DAO tooling, and future of work; projects advancing reputation, governance & decision making, operations (accounting, sales automation, inventory management, talent, etc), community, and contributor tooling!
OpenGuitar mentions working on a peer-governed platform and includes elements of community involvement and governance. However, it is not clear if it directly advances the specific criteria listed such as organisations on-chain, B2B SaaS evolution, or contributor tooling.
Commercial viability or perennial Public Goods: projects addressing a clear need for a specific target user and with the ability to continue to deliver value over time (financial sustainability through business model and/or immutability)
The project aims to create a governance structure and a community-driven learning platform which suggests long-term value delivery. However, the sustainability model is not detailed sufficiently to assess commercial viability or perennial public good status.
Maximum project development duration of 12 weeks (i.e. value delivered within 12 weeks)
The project timeline indicates value delivery starting from Q4/24 and extending into Q2/25, which exceeds the 12 weeks development duration limit.
Threshold: Projects must declare a “threshold” (minimum amount of funds needed to complete the project/feature/prototype and deliver value). Thoroughness in defining their threshold and feasibility (threshold within the range of match-funding available) will be key for approval into the round. Projects not able to attain the threshold (with combined donations + match funding), will not receive match funding but can still keep donations.
The project does not declare a specific threshold or detailed financial requirement in the provided information, making it difficult to assess feasibility and thoroughness.
General Criteria: Incomplete, poorly structured, unfeasible, or otherwise poorly conceived applications will be rejected.
The application provides a reasonable amount of detail but lacks specific elements such as clear financial thresholds and exact timelines, leaving some doubts about completeness and feasibility.